Skip to content

Thai Floods: At Klong Sam Wa Sluice Gate, a microcosm of conflict

08 November 2011
A man rests on a flooded pier on the Sam Wa Canal on the Eastern border of Bangkok on November 1, 2011 (Photo by Saksith Saiyasombut)

Originally published at Siam Voices on November 7, 2011

A man rests on a flooded pier on the Sam Wa Canal on the Eastern border of Bangkok on November 1, 2011 (Photo by Saksith Saiyasombut)

Things seem calm on the bridge overlooking the Klong (Canal) Sam Wa Sluice Gate on the Eastern border of Bangkok. Just a few dozens of onlookers observe the water streaming through the gate through the gaps left and right, while around police officers take their lunch break under large tents. On the day before (Monday, Oct 31) that however, things seemed less than calm:

In one incident, parts of which were broadcast on local television news, a large group of angry residents in the Min Buri section of eastern Bangkok staged a rally starting Sunday to force the Bangkok Metropolitan Administration to open a floodgate to drain water to the large Saen Saep canal nearby. Later, the residents marched to the floodgate and tried to destroy a concrete gate and sandbag wall around it with sledgehammers.

The residents complained that floodwaters are growing increasingly unhealthy, with rotten smells. But officials have said there’s a limit to how much water they can release because of the need to protect key economic assets in the area, including a market and the Bang Chan industrial estate nearby. Later, officials agreed to raise the gate some to drain off some water, and the residents backed down.

Frustrations Rising with Floodwaters in Thailand“, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2011

There was scuffling between local residents and the police (see footage here), the one side unleashing their anger of being left alone to the force of nature and the other protecting one of the last flood barriers preventing the high tides flushing into the canals of inner Bangkok.

“We understand the anger of the people,” says Somkuan Puengsap, a police colonel overlooking a 100-man strong police force to protect the gate from further damage. “The problem is, we police officers have no rights to open the sluice gates by ourselves,” Somkuan continued, “We are only there to acknowledge the problem and try to mediate between the two conflicting parties.”

Somkuan admitted that he has never seen anything like this before, as flooding has never been a problem in this area. Other police officers who requested to be unnamed have expressed their frustration that they are at the receiving end of political games between the government of prime minister Yingluck Shinawatra and the Bangkok governor Sukhamband Paribatra. The latter’s Bangkok Metropolitan Authority (BMA) has been overruled by the federal government, when…

The prime minister invoked the disaster prevention law on Oct 21 to take full control of all flood operations as runoff from the North started surging into Bangkok. “I have ordered a committee to negotiate with residents [living upstream] to narrow the gate so that less overflow will enter Bangkok,” she said.

Ms Yingluck said the gate had to be narrowed to regulate water flow. “We are talking to residents and we believe they will cooperate,” she said. On Monday she ordered the BMA to widen the sluice gate to one metre after angry protesters destroyed parts of it while police officers looked on.

PM backs down on sluice gate“, Bangkok Post, November 3, 2011

The same feeling is shared by one resident North in viewing distance of the gate. Sitting crossed-legged on a stone bench, Thamon Yangprasert appeared calm and relaxed, overseeing the canal, which has overspilled to the sides knee-high. But when asked about how this could all happen, he lashed out against the political opponents of the Pheu Thai Party-led government: “It all comes down to politics! The Democrat Party (which Sukhumband belongs to), they want to remove Yingluck as prime minister.”

“They have been stalling that water everywhere, in Ayutthaya, Wang Noi, they have put up barriers, so it cannot get into Bangkok. They are playing a cruel joke, because all the people out in the provinces are all red shirts! Nobody has voted for them! And now they want to remove Yingluck,” he continues, hinting at the (small) possibility of what has been coined a ‘water coup’, whereas the Yingluck administration gets blamed for the slow flood relief efforts, opening the chance for the military to take take over.

A sign that reads "We must open the sluice gate" hangs at the Klong Sam Wa Sluice Gate on the Eastern border of Bangkok on November 1, 2011 (Photo by Saksith Saiyasombut)

Residents on the South side of the gate are now sharing the pain with their neighbors. “I didn’t mind them demanding to open up the gates. But then they started to chop off parts of the gate and they are still not happy enough, they demanded even more. The water level now is not how it’s supposed to be – I can accept that, but when they said they want it to be completely opened up, that I cannot accept,” says Pimon Jeanjuer, as his house and property is now flooded as well.

While Pimon can understand their frustrations, he criticizes them of being short-sighted as his son’s job in an industrial park in Ban Chan, along the Klong San Saeb, is now threatened to be flooded as well. Locals have gathered to discuss the situation and also to counter demands by other residents to fully open the gate, as they have prepared a letter to the officials explaining their side. That would be the first time that they would have gotten in contact with an official – a sense of abandonment is felt on both sides of the fence, as both Thanom and Pimon say that nobody from the BMA or other local authorities have showed up before to explain the situation to the residents.

While the gate has been fixed now, some say that the inner city of Bangkok is now at risk as the Klong Sam Wa flows directly into the Klong San Saeb, a vital canal leading into inner heart of the city, including the Sukhumvit area. Dr Seree Supharatid, Director of the Disaster Warning Centre at Rangsit University, argues on Thai television that this Klong will “definitely be not able to hold the mass of water coming in from the North” and predicts overflow of “no higher than one meter”.

The area surrounding Klong Sam Wa Sluice Gate is already flooded with badly smelling water. The contention in the community reflects a microcosm of conflict to save the center of the capital, while the outskirts bear the brunt of the deluge: the neighborhood South of the gate is angry at the local authorities for giving in to the protesters, while those opposite in the North feel that their area has sacrificed to protect the water from gushing into inner Bangkok. Either way, they cannot shake off their feeling that they have been victims of a political scuffle between the government and the BMA.

Saksith Saiyasombut is a Thai blogger and journalist currently based in Bangkok, Thailand. He can be followed on Twitter @Saksith and now also on his public Facebook page here.

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 76 other followers

%d bloggers like this: